About

This is a blog for the online class in summer 2010. My plan is to use this as the space for my "notes", clarification, and to relay anything of interest to students.

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

India: rich, or poor, or both?

So, hey, in case there are more students who have questions similar to Brandon's:
    When you visited India in 2006 when homes had piped water, some other villages didn't and their water supply actually worsened? How do you think this is possible when I read about India being an economy that's established and has one of the most phenomenal resorts in the world?
Answering this will require a lot of discussions.  So, I will focus only on one aspect, which is the assumption that is built into the question, that then triggers the questions.  And that assumption is "about India being an economy that's established"

The popular perception that India is some kind of an advanced economy that has even begun to give us here in the US a run for our jobs and money is largely a myth.  I don't mean to dismiss a whole bunch of data such as the Indian businesses such as Infosys, Wipro, HCL pretty much running the Information Technology (IT) back-operations for a large part of the world, including the US--the kind of data that feeds into comedy routines as well as political rhetoric.  Or the data such as medical tourism, and fertility tourism.  Or data such as India having sophisticated industries, and a labor force that is qualified enough to design $2,000 cars and, recently, an iPad-like gadget that could potentially sell for as low as $10.  Yes, all those, and many more, are for real.

So, then why do I write the kind of opinion pieces that made Brandon type that email?

For starters, how about the following statistic that might be simply way too shocking.  So, make sure you have fastened that seat belt on your chair, and hold on to it really, really, tightly:

After being conditioned to images from Somalia, Ethiopia, and many other African countries, we might be surprised to read that:
Acute poverty prevails in eight Indian states, including Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal, together accounting for more poor people than in the 26 poorest African nations combined, a new 'multidimensional' measure of global poverty has said.

The new measure, called the Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI), was developed and applied by the Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative with UNDP support.

It will be featured in the forthcoming 20 th anniversary edition of the UNDP Human Development Report.
Which states are those?
(421 million in Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Orissa, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, and West Bengal) than in the 26 poorest African countries combined (410 million).
Doesn't surprise me on bit.

Well, getting you this statistic was easy because I blogged about it a few days ago!  (For that matter, most of what I have here is a compilation from my blog!)  BTW, click here if you want only India-related posts at my blog; I have filtered them through the label of "India")

Everybody from Thomas "The World is Flat" Friedman to politicians who frighten us about jobs being offshored to India are presenting only one of India's economic characteristics.  What they don't do is to discuss the fact that India has the kind of poverty that I just described, or that millions have no access to piped drinking water ... or even worse: India is home to the largest population on the planet the defecates in a daily basis in the open.  In simple terms, if and when you visit India, you might be shocked to find shit all over the place.  Men pissing in broad daylight by the side of busy traffic.

The priorities for the country's governments, and the people, seem to be very different from how I would imagine the response ought to be:
India now has 2.5 million places of worship, but only 1.5 million schools and barely seventy-five thousand hospitals. Pilgrimages now account for more than 50 percent of all package tours, while the bigger pilgrimage sites now vie with the Taj Mahal for the title of most visited in the country: the Balaji Temple in Tirupati had 23 million visitors last year
The reality is also that the part of India I visit--the southern part where my parents and sister live--is a progressive part of the country.  I don't mean economic prosperity as much as indicators such as literacy, life expectancy, infant mortality, treatment of women, ... I have barely set my feet in some of the worst areas in India.

It probably was about when Europe was clawing its way out of its Dark Ages when it was the last time that India might have been way more advanced compared to the rest of the world.  "The twin stories of India and China are the most dramatic in the world economy. In 1820, the two countries contributed to nearly half of the world's income. In 1950, their share was less than a tenth"  Now, it is one poor country.  Unfortunately, and increasingly so, the poverty doesn't get any respect, to quote Rodney Dangerfield, and this means that neither India's government nor the rest of the world particularly worries about the almost half a billion poor people.  Or a slightly smaller number that every third Indian is poor.  I hope India will address this challenge sooner than later.

I am guessing that I have generated more questions while addressing your question through this "lecture" ... hey, this is why we have college education .... As far as I am concerned, I stop educating myself when I stop asking questions, both trivial and profound.

ps: yes, India is also home to some fantastic resorts, most of which I have not visited because of my budget constraints :)  Including this resort owned by the family that is friends with a high school classmate of mine!  As the name itself suggests, it is one pricey place ...

Sunday, July 25, 2010

The "wrap up" task

The task I have for you here will not be a surprise if you have been in any of classes, particularly at the upper-division level.  First, I will describe the task, and then the rationale

The "fun" task, which you need to complete (preferably) before the end of Wednesday:
Without changing the "Subject" line, and by sending your reply to the class (the geog310 address), tell us about the most interesting, exciting, or just "I did not know that before", thing you gained from this class.  
Note:
  • Unlike with the assignments, do not merely email me
    • Make sure you respond to the entire class.
  • Do not change the "Subject" line
    • So that we will all immediately know the context of your email, and 
    • It will also help me collate them.
  • If there is more than one that grabbed your attention
    • You may choose to write about only one, or 
    • Write about 'em all ...
  • But, write only after spending a few minutes thinking through the proceedings of the entire term.
So, why this task?
Taking a course is more than for the mere purpose of checking off on a box of requirements for a major or minor, or whatever.  Even if a course is one you took only because it was requirement, at least to faculty like me, every course is yet another window into making order out of the chaos that life is.  Of course, the nature of inquiry is different from, say, philosophy to geography to biology.  
However, in the process of taking courses towards graduation, more often than not we fail to take stock of what we have accomplished ... and that is not what I prefer.  In my paradigm of teaching and learning, students and teachers would conclude the term with a discussion of the entire term.  We have all done this as kids, for instance, when our parents asked us, "so, what happened at school today?"  For whatever reasons, we don't continue with this wonderful practice as we get into higher education.
As with the evaluation rubric for papers, which I suggested you can use for other classes too, I recommend that you do the same for all the other courses you take as well.  Imagine this scenario: at the end of every term, even if your instructor does not require of you, well, you spend some time thinking about every class you took (even if it was not a successful experience) and jot down your thoughts on what you gained.  At the end of your college experience, such a compilation could be worth way more than the diploma itself.  And you will have a fantastic scrapbook of sorts in the process.
Well, now you know what to expect at the end of the term if you ever find yourself in one of my classes again :)

I look forward to your responses.

PS: this is NOT an opportunity for you to evaluate the class, the course, or the instructor.  You need to only reflect on the value added to your knowledge-base.