A few thoughts related to the task:
- First, a clarification about the suggested 800-word limit. There is no hassle whatsoever if you exceed that count. But, if you are at, say 682 words, that alone should raise a red flag that you have not sufficiently developed your arguments. (additional clarification: that 682 was an arbitrary #; I did not choose that because there was any paper of that length!)
- Given the relatively short paper, the quotes you use to strengthen the arguments can't be way too much. Because, the more lengthy quotes you use, the less space you have to convey your point. So, you need to learn to judiciously use quotes, versus paraphrasing and summarizing ideas.
- While I might sound repetitive, it is my job to keep reminding you about staying focused on the task.
- While I might sound repetitive, it is my job to keep reminding you about staying focused on the task.
- (get the joke? ha ha)
- (get the joke? ha ha)
- Seriously. Very rarely in my classes I tell students that they can write a paper on anything. As you would have noticed by now, I ask you to submit essays that are in response to focused questions. So, even if you are used to writing papers on topics of your own choosing, you need to switch gears here. I do this way for a bunch of reasons. Two in particular:
- We faculty, for various reasons, don't do a good job of teaching students how to think and write, but then turn around and tell students that they should submit papers on any topic of their choice. This almost always ends up doing disservice to students and learning, and society then complains about the falling communication skills of students. So, over the years I have modified my pedagogy.
- Increasingly, resources on the web have made it temptingly easy for students to put together papers that might contain a lot of borrowed material of various sorts, which then forces me to become a policeman. I hate that task (which I have not had to do for the last six years; yay!!!), and my approach of focused essay questions preclude those to a large extent.
- However, I do want students to get that experience of choosing their own essay topic--it is, after all, one of the best ways to learn. Which is why the third essay will not be in response to a question from me. More on this in another email.
- Ok, on to content ... (did I hear you mutter, "high time"? hmmm ...!!!)
I can extend Ochonu's arguments even further. Just because I am from India, (and given that I opine a lot!) people erroneously conclude that I ought to be able to answer every question about India. I simply can't. But, what Ochonu warns is less about such a curiosity-driven inquiry, versus convictions that are based on ignorance and stereotypes. For instance, it is one thing to ask me whether the caste system is still in place in India--which is the inquiry based on curiosity--versus concluding that India is not doing well because of the caste system there.
We can keep extending this further to pretty much every region on the planet. Which is the biggest take away from the essay you wrote--while this notion was couched within the context of Africa and the materials on sub-Saharan Africa, the moral of the story, as we say, has a global reach. By learning about the world, we will then stay away from stereotypes and simplification, and begin to appreciate and understand the complexities amongst, and within, the regions. - Hey, hey, stop rolling the eyeballs, and pay attention here :) Do not become yet another example that is the reason for the discussion here.
Finally, if you have read all these, then here is something that I hope will at least make you chuckle :)
No comments:
Post a Comment