About

This is a blog for the online class in summer 2010. My plan is to use this as the space for my "notes", clarification, and to relay anything of interest to students.

Thursday, July 15, 2010

More feedback on map

So, apparently I emailed you the feedback on the map-work task related to North Africa and the Middle East, in which I wrote, ahem,
 I will soon email you my feedback and grade
Only to completely forget following up on it!

Thanks to the reminder from Erik, I realized the omission.  Unlike the pop song from a couple of years ago, I hope it is not too late to apologize ...  Or, should I say, oops, I did it again!
Ok, I will stop with this, and just say sorry.
I emailed all my feedback, and have already heard from one student as well ...

Here I am about two hours later, and a sudden thought: why waste this opportunity!  I might as well share more thoughts related to the North Africa/Middle Eastern region.  (I do wonder if anybody is actually listening though.  But, I suppose I get paid for it whether anybody is listening or not.  Aahh, that old philosophical problem of tree falling in the forest!)

As one student noted, because it is mostly a desert area, population seems to be concentrated in a few places were the conditions are less awful compared to the other areas.
A contrast to the US, the student notes.
The contrast are the cities of Phoenix and Las Vegas (the city in the photo here)--two cities that are large, with the fastest growth rates over the last decade, and these are in awfully hot and arid places when we have lots of more hospitable areas in the country where water, in particular, might not be a serious issue to fight over.
Yet, here were have these two cities.
To which, my remark was that this is yet another evidence of the remarkable affluence we enjoy here in the US.  As the old saying goes, with money, water will flow uphill!

Another student noted the value in Azar Nafisi's remark:
 “To talk of “the Muslim world” is to reduce countries, cultures, and histories as vastly different as Malaysia, Indonesia, Afghanistan, Turkey, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and Morocco to a single aspect, namely religion”. 
We don't think of a monolithic Christian world, because we even intuitively understand that there are enormous differences based on language, ethnicity, the emphasis in the belief, .... yet, we (not this class of students, of course) are often ready to believe that the "Muslim world" is all one.  I mean, it does not take a professor to figure out that Muslims in Serbia might be very different from those in Bangladesh or Saudi Arabia.  


Speaking of Saudi Arabia, I "wrote" in one student's assignment that for centuries that was merely "Arabia" ... which is why we have the "Arabian Nights" and not the "Saudi Arabian Nights" :)  BTW, the collection of tales that we refer to as the Arabian Nights include classics such as: Aladdin and the magic lamp, Ali Baba and the forty thieves, Sindbad the Sailor, ... a rich treasure.  Again, I can't but wonder why we don't discuss such historical literary pieces at our university ... Well, there I go again on a tangential point.  
Hmmm, what was I talking about? :) Oh, yeah, "Saudi Arabia" has that prefix now because of its ruling family that is the House of Saud.

Yet another student noted that
"the geographical boundary of the Sahara separates culture, where countries residing in N. Africa actually view themselves as identifying more with the cultures of Europe than of the countries south of the desert."
Again, yes indeed.  By now we would have cleared any misconception that somehow everywhere in Africa the physical and human geography is the same.  I also added an anecdote about a graduate schoolmate of mine and his wife, who were both from Tunisia.  (In your mind can you now draw a map of North Africa and picture Tunisia there?)  They looked and behaved very European, though his accent was Arabic ...

Finally, as a rejoinder to a student who had lots of interesting things about Iran, well, that country, which we all know is Islamic, is also home to Mt. Ararat--well technically this is on Turkey's side of their borders.
So, why does one mountain deserve a mention here?
In the Judeo-Christian tradition (i.e., Jewish, Christian, and Islamic) it is believed that Noah's Ark came to rest upon Mt. Ararat

Despite your track record as a quiet class, I shall look forward to additional thoughts/comments :)

No comments:

Post a Comment