About

This is a blog for the online class in summer 2010. My plan is to use this as the space for my "notes", clarification, and to relay anything of interest to students.

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Comments on Essay 1

I have completed reading and evaluating the first of the essays for this class.  I will soon email you individually my comments and the letter grades. 

A few thoughts related to the assignment
  • Focus on the writing.  
    • Improving the thinking and writing skills of students is a goal that we have in most courses, and the world outside also expects college graduates to be able to think and write at a certain level.
      • Spell-check, more than anything, is critical.  And this includes paying attention to words like "their" and "there"--even though they pass the spell-check filter, "their" is chance that the "write" word is not being used.  (Did I demonstrate the problem through this example here?)
  • Focus on the task.
    • When the directions require that "You need to include the appropriate quotes from Murphy and Wade", well, you need to weave into the essay appropriate quotes from those articles.  After all, this essay, like the rest of the assignments, is an opportunity for you to demonstrate that you have done the readings, too.
  • On Wade and Murphy
    • One of the important points that Wade makes, and absolutely relevant to this course, is the distinction between geography courses that are focused on specific topics--like GIS--versus a regional geography course like this one.  We can then extend Wade's observations to many other regional courses.  These regional courses are the "old" types of geography courses that have largely gone out of fashion, and Wade argues that these are far too important for us to stop teaching.  Not teaching these is the equivalent of the proverbial throwing out the baby along with the bath water.
  • On the quiz itself
    • The idea was not at all to put you on the defensive, or make you feel embarrassed, about your performance in the quiz.  In fact, none of the tasks I ever assign--in any course that I teach--is ever along those lines.  The questions in the quiz are essentially to trigger an awareness that there is a lot going on in the world that we might not be familiar with, and this range of questions is also representative of the breadth of geography itself.
    • Furthermore, the questions are not in the best format that I would like.  But some are better than others.  For instance, the question about Indonesia is relatively well-phrased.  However, the question about the leading exporter in the world is not, because of the ambiguity in terms of exports of manufactured goods, versus total exports of goods and services.  And with passage of time, the answer then is far from being a straightforward one.  Actually, we can complicate this even more by bringing in the idea of Purchasing Power Parity versus exchange rates; but we will reserve this for a 4xx-level course :)
  • On arguing your point
    • It is absolutely ok to challenge the ideas in the assigned materials.  But, arguments--whether in agreement or to point out the flaws--ought to be based on specifics. 
In the individual emails to you, the attachments will contain my specific comments.  Let me know if you think I can be clearer with the comments.
For now, I shall watch out for the first of the map-work assignments.

Finally, it looks like in the schedule of tasks I have consistently erred in the day of the week and the date for when the essays are due.  E.g.: The schedule says Friday the 26th--but, 26th was a Saturday.  I ought to accept responsibility on that one, which means that even if your assignments come in only by the date (and not the day) well, it will be ok.  My thanks to the student who pointed this out.

No comments:

Post a Comment