First, usually I do have structured discussions in my online classes. However, a six-week summer session is too short for that, which is why I don't have discussion questions. But, feel free to engage me and/or the entire class in discussions.
Now, on to the content; the student notes:
I always thought that Geography was sort of a mixture of anthropology, history, geology and sociology. Covering the peoples who live and have lived in an area or region, and how the unique features of the earth in that region have influenced and shaped human actions through history. For example, Rome being built where it was because of the rivers close by and the 7 hills which offer protection from attack.
However, after reading the two assigned readings for Essay 1, I find myself doubting my definition and feeling like I don't have a strong grasp of what geography is and thus I am not really certain what I am supposed to learn and come away with from this course.
I suppose the best answer to this is a comical "yes" .... let me explain this bizarre response ...
If the essays by Charles Wade and Alec Murphy left you wondering what exactly Geography is about, and what is one supposed to get from this field of inquiry, well, join the club. You are not alone. We geographers wrestle with this identity question everyday.
In fact, this is a question that took up a major chunk of the capstone course, GEOG495, that I taught this past spring term. I think I drove the students in the class a tad crazy by harping on this theme; but then, come to think of it, I get paid to drive students crazy with questions. (Though, I then remind myself about the fate that befell the teacher who annoyed the most--Socrates!)
I suppose in this course I can't go as deep into this theme as I would in the capstone course. So, I will restrict myself to a few comments, but will happily provide more if there is any interest at all ...
Yes, geography has always been multi- and cross-disciplinary--sometimes it might seem like the discipline is like anthropology while at other times it might seem like geology or economics ... One reason is that geography has a long history; after all, to understand the planet ("geo") has been a project that, I suppose, ever since humans started thinking. To some extent, it is then like a mother of many disciplines that came much later. We have intellectual cousins in various fields of intellectual inquiry.
But, by the same token, one criticism has been that if Geography is about everything, then perhaps it is nothing. It is one hell of a serious critique. Because, for instance, a physicist has a clear idea of the discipline and where the disciplinary boundaries are. But that is not the case with geographers. And when in the modern world of intellectual activities, it is specialization that defines disciplines and the professionals, the spread out discipline makes it seem as if Geography has no specific focus at all.
You see how important and interesting the question you raised is? Absolutely fascinating, and we can spend hours/days talking about this. But, I shall pause here on this and wait for any follow-up the class might have.
So, then what would you get from this course, or how can you make sense of this course? On the one hand, it is kind of ridiculous to group countries into "regions" and study them. Because, there is almost always tremendous differences within the regions with respect to their physical and human geographic attributes. Take Sub-Saharan Africa, for instance. Only a completely mis-informed person would think there is no difference internally ... and this is a question that Moses Ochonu discusses, right? Neither is there any kind of "scientific law" that we could apply to regions. I.e., we could not possibly predict that if a country is located in a certain region, then a certain "x" will be the economic output, for instance.
This course is, therefore, to be approached not at an upper division level, but, as I noted quite early on, is really a freshman- or a sophomore-level course. This is one way in which we can begin to appreciate the tremendous complexity in the world. For instance, when we look at the Indian Subcontinent, in the first place, we begin to understand where it is located in the first place. Then we realize the immense internal differences in every possible way--deserts to valleys to languages to religions to ... The course then slowly wakes us up the reality that the ideas that we might have of different parts of the world could be absolutely screwed up. Perhaps it will then force us to understand more about the world and the different issues.
An example of a very big picture thinking on this is the book, Guns, Germs, and Steel
I hope I have stayed on task in responding to the question and have not wandered off ... I will be delighted to "talk" more if any of you have pointed follow-up questions
And, yes, thanks for the question that prompted this response.
No comments:
Post a Comment