About

This is a blog for the online class in summer 2010. My plan is to use this as the space for my "notes", clarification, and to relay anything of interest to students.

Friday, July 9, 2010

Essay 3 Question

Hey, if you are like me ... well, I feel sorry for you ... ha ha ha :)

Ok, if you are like me, then you are thinking it will be neat if the sun's light and heat were evenly distributed throughout the year. We could have 70 degree days all the time.
In fact, a few years ago, a mathematician/physicist proposed--as a thought experiment--that we have a lot of nuclear bombs to get rid of, and those might be enough to blast the moon into pieces.
Once the moon is gone, then Earth will no longer feel the moon's gravitational effect, which is one of the reasons why the planet is tilted.  It is the tilt that causes the seasons as we experience them the farther we are from the equator.
Bingo, 70 degree days forever here in Oregon!

Oh well ... at least we don't live in Fairbanks, Alaska, where in a same year temperatures could go from 60 below zero in winter to a scorching 95-degree long summer day.  Yes, the place has the world record for such a temperature range!
A couple of summers ago, it was a 84-degree day that I experienced in Fairbanks--it was quite a surprise to experience that much heat near the Arctic Circle.
Even more surprising was the size of the mosquitoes--they seem to be way larger than the ones that suck my blood when I am in India.  But then, here in the US we super-size everything, eh ... muahahaha

So, you are thinking, "what do all these have to do with Essay 3?" and the answer is, well, you are absolutely right ... but, that was a whole lot of geography, right? ...

For Essay 3:
The materials I have for you for next week are about southern and eastern Europe.  Realistically, I don't see how everything can be related to into a single thesis that can be discussed in an essay.
But, I bet you will be able to weave into the same essay at least two of those materials.
So, your task will be to first read through all of them, and to watch the video, too.  Then, think about all that new info in your head.  Allow them to settle down--which is when you go for a bike ride, or simply lie down and catch a few rays.
By then, you will have had at least a couple of ideas that you will then want to work on.  Formulate a thesis  and go forth and write that essay.  You will be a tad constrained by working only with the materials I have given you.  So, you have to (yes, have to) get at least one additional reference material that you can use in support of your discussions.  This additional reference cannot be some random website, and nor can it be a mere news report.  It must be a credible analytical piece, which can be from an academic journal, or non-academic publications.
I hope I am making sense.  Let me know if there is anything that I can clarify here.
A reminder: you can operate with either the day or the date as the deadline for Essay 3.

ps: the World Cup comes to an end this weekend.

Thursday, July 8, 2010

Essay 2 Feedback

Hey, I have completed grading Essay 2.  I will soon email you the comments/grade.
A few thoughts related to the task:
  • First, a clarification about the suggested 800-word limit.  There is no hassle whatsoever if you exceed that count.  But, if you are at, say 682 words, that alone should raise a red flag that you have not sufficiently developed your arguments.  (additional clarification: that 682 was an arbitrary #; I did not choose that because there was any paper of that length!)
  • Given the relatively short paper, the quotes you use to strengthen the arguments can't be way too much.  Because, the more lengthy quotes you use, the less space you have to convey your point.  So, you need to learn to judiciously use quotes, versus paraphrasing and summarizing ideas. 
  • While I might sound repetitive, it is my job to keep reminding you about staying focused on the task.
    • While I might sound repetitive, it is my job to keep reminding you about staying focused on the task. 
    • (get the joke?  ha ha)
    • (get the joke?  ha ha)
  • Seriously. Very rarely in my classes I tell students that they can write a paper on anything.  As you would have noticed by now, I ask you to submit essays that are in response to focused questions.  So, even if you are used to writing papers on topics of your own choosing, you need to switch gears here. I do this way for a bunch of reasons.  Two in particular:
    • We faculty, for various reasons, don't do a good job of teaching students how to think and write, but then turn around and tell students that they should submit papers on any topic of their choice.  This almost always ends up doing disservice to students and learning, and society then complains about the falling communication skills of students.  So, over the years I have modified my pedagogy.
    • Increasingly, resources on the web have made it temptingly easy for students to put together papers that might contain a lot of borrowed material of various sorts, which then forces me to become a policeman.  I hate that task (which I have not had to do for the last six years; yay!!!), and my approach of focused essay questions preclude those to a large extent.
  • However, I do want students to get that experience of choosing their own essay topic--it is, after all, one of the best ways to learn. Which is why the third essay will not be in response to a question from me.  More on this in another email.
  • Ok, on to content ... (did I hear you mutter, "high time"?  hmmm ...!!!)
    I can extend Ochonu's arguments even further.  Just because I am from India, (and given that I opine a lot!) people erroneously conclude that I ought to be able to answer every question about India.  I simply can't.  But, what Ochonu warns is less about such a curiosity-driven inquiry, versus convictions that are based on ignorance and stereotypes.  For instance, it is one thing to ask me whether the caste system is still in place in India--which is the inquiry based on curiosity--versus concluding that India is not doing well because of the caste system there. 
    We can keep extending this further to pretty much every region on the planet.  Which is the biggest take away from the essay you wrote--while this notion was couched within the context of Africa and the materials on sub-Saharan Africa, the moral of the story, as we say, has a global reach.  By learning about the world, we will then stay away from stereotypes and simplification, and begin to appreciate and understand the complexities amongst, and within, the regions.
  • Hey, hey, stop rolling the eyeballs, and pay attention here :)  Do not become yet another example that is the reason for the discussion here.
Notice that I have built in many hyperlinks here.  If anything interests you, and you want to discuss it, I am ready ...
Finally, if you have read all these, then here is something that I hope will at least make you chuckle :)

Tuesday, July 6, 2010

Map work #1

Hey, as soon as I am done with this, I will email you individually my feedback on your work.

First, make sure you have addressed all the components of the map work assignment.  Once you read through and gather the information I require for the map work, I bet you will have picked up enough and more with respect to the assignment.  But, above that, I am confident that you will be impressed with yourself for having learnt stuff you didn't know prior to that ... and, as I mentioned in response to couple of your observations, perhaps you, like me, will be all the more thankful and excited that you live here in the good ol' US of A :)

I found it pretty interesting that The Economist had a lengthy piece on the wheat rust that I had required you to read.  Doesn't the map on the left make you worry?  I mean, these are the kind of analyses where I have to search hard for some good news!  I tell you, all these viruses and other organisms are always waiting around for us to drop our guard and, before we know it, ... kaboom!
Anyway, I strongly recommend that piece, now that you have an idea of the issue from the Uganda article you read.

I might take up the issue in detail in the Global Issues class that I am scheduled to teach in the fall term.  (was that a smooth advertisement or what!!!)

As a couple of you noted, the Sahel is an important part of Africa that makes a lot of sense when we talk about sub-Saharan Africa.  When you try to understand the regions, you will find that in many cases the "edges" of the region are zones of transition in a number of different ways. In the case of Sub-Saharan Africa, the zone of transition is called the "Sahel." Physical and human geographic characteristics markedly differ between above and below the Sahel.

We can see such zones of transition all around the world, though perhaps not as pronounced as it is with Africa.

While comparing Nigeria and the US, one student commented that oil spills seem to be common to both, while the magnitudes are different.  Yes, indeed.  Nigerians are all too familiar with oil spills.  (The photo, which is from this AP story, is captioned thus: In this June 20, 2010 photo, a men stands in an oil slick covering a creek near Bodo City in the oil-rich Niger Delta region of Nigeria.) 
One of the many dark sides of such spills is that they tend to be at economically and ecologically rich areas.  The delta region in Nigeria is one of those stories.  

Finally, in case you wonder why I follow this kind of a teaching/learning approach ... where I don't "lecture" for you to take notes ... I believe in learning-by-doing.  In this course, and in the online mode, I then provide you with the guidelines in order to provide a structure to that kind of learning,  And then I come back at the end of it all with my clarifying notes.  To some extent, it is also why I don't use formal texts in most of the courses I teach--all the more so when so much material is so easily and freely available these days.
I am hoping that you don't find a need for a transition time (an educational Sahel?) into this format :)

Any questions?  Additional thoughts?

PS: in case you didn't keep track of the news, Africa is out of the World Cup ...

Monday, July 5, 2010

Grading delayed :(

Hey, according to my schedule, I would have by now wrapped up grading and returning the map assignment and the second essay.  But, a slight mishap, thanks to the notorious blue screen of death last night.

All is not lost--my computer is alive and well.  But, I did lose the Word documents that were open.  As has been my past practice, I had, ahem, all the assignment documents open, which means I re-start that process all over :)

Hence, a slight delay in the feedback ...

But, hey, at least summer is finally here ... and the temperature will reach into the 90s in two days?

Friday, July 2, 2010

Africa, maps, and ... hotdogs?

You may have noticed that there is no essay due next week.  It is for a reason that I had set up the schedule of tasks this way--after the Fourth of July hotdogs (!) I figured that you might not be quite ready to sit down to write a 800-word essay.

What?  I can't hear you ...
did you say thanks?  Aaawwww....  :)

(Yes, in my "real world" classes, this is the kind of awful humor with which I torture students!)

But, don't relax too much though--I do have a map-work assignment next week.

A couple of quick comments:

  • The length of essays--800 words--is a suggested length for two important reasons:
    • Without this suggestion, there is a possibility that students might not know whether the question requires a short essay at 250 words, or merits a 10-page treatment
    • Most newspaper columns are at this length.  In other words, my idea is that if you were to share your essay with people who have sufficient background information, then they should be able to understand right away what your arguments are.  In courses like this that are about breadth, I tend to emphasize this approach.
  • When you copy/paste maps into Word, you also need to ensure that you are not distorting the map. 
    • I.e., just because you want the graphic to fit into a part of the page, you should not shrink it alone one dimension alone
      • Make sure that both the length and the width are reduced or enlarged by the same ratio.
  • And, yes, provide the map assignment as one single document
    • The text and graphic should be in the same.  If you learn to do this now, you will find it wonderfully useful later on in your job, and personal life too.
Finally, in keeping with the World Cup motif, well, as I type this, the Ghana-Uruguay match is underway.  I noted earlier that the entire African continent is cheering for Ghana.  Let us see if that will be enough to propel them into the semi-finals.

Have a "fun"tastic Fourth of July weekend :)

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Comments on Essay 1

I have completed reading and evaluating the first of the essays for this class.  I will soon email you individually my comments and the letter grades. 

A few thoughts related to the assignment
  • Focus on the writing.  
    • Improving the thinking and writing skills of students is a goal that we have in most courses, and the world outside also expects college graduates to be able to think and write at a certain level.
      • Spell-check, more than anything, is critical.  And this includes paying attention to words like "their" and "there"--even though they pass the spell-check filter, "their" is chance that the "write" word is not being used.  (Did I demonstrate the problem through this example here?)
  • Focus on the task.
    • When the directions require that "You need to include the appropriate quotes from Murphy and Wade", well, you need to weave into the essay appropriate quotes from those articles.  After all, this essay, like the rest of the assignments, is an opportunity for you to demonstrate that you have done the readings, too.
  • On Wade and Murphy
    • One of the important points that Wade makes, and absolutely relevant to this course, is the distinction between geography courses that are focused on specific topics--like GIS--versus a regional geography course like this one.  We can then extend Wade's observations to many other regional courses.  These regional courses are the "old" types of geography courses that have largely gone out of fashion, and Wade argues that these are far too important for us to stop teaching.  Not teaching these is the equivalent of the proverbial throwing out the baby along with the bath water.
  • On the quiz itself
    • The idea was not at all to put you on the defensive, or make you feel embarrassed, about your performance in the quiz.  In fact, none of the tasks I ever assign--in any course that I teach--is ever along those lines.  The questions in the quiz are essentially to trigger an awareness that there is a lot going on in the world that we might not be familiar with, and this range of questions is also representative of the breadth of geography itself.
    • Furthermore, the questions are not in the best format that I would like.  But some are better than others.  For instance, the question about Indonesia is relatively well-phrased.  However, the question about the leading exporter in the world is not, because of the ambiguity in terms of exports of manufactured goods, versus total exports of goods and services.  And with passage of time, the answer then is far from being a straightforward one.  Actually, we can complicate this even more by bringing in the idea of Purchasing Power Parity versus exchange rates; but we will reserve this for a 4xx-level course :)
  • On arguing your point
    • It is absolutely ok to challenge the ideas in the assigned materials.  But, arguments--whether in agreement or to point out the flaws--ought to be based on specifics. 
In the individual emails to you, the attachments will contain my specific comments.  Let me know if you think I can be clearer with the comments.
For now, I shall watch out for the first of the map-work assignments.

Finally, it looks like in the schedule of tasks I have consistently erred in the day of the week and the date for when the essays are due.  E.g.: The schedule says Friday the 26th--but, 26th was a Saturday.  I ought to accept responsibility on that one, which means that even if your assignments come in only by the date (and not the day) well, it will be ok.  My thanks to the student who pointed this out.

Saturday, June 26, 2010

What is geography?

Hey, this lengthy note is in response to an email I received from a student.  I have deleted the student's name from the email because (a) I haven't contacted the student for an "ok" on this, and (b) the content is way too important and interesting for me to wait for it :)

First, usually I do have structured discussions in my online classes.  However, a six-week summer session is too short for that, which is why I don't have discussion questions.  But, feel free to engage me and/or the entire class in discussions.

Now, on to the content; the student notes:
I always thought that Geography was sort of a mixture of anthropology, history, geology and sociology. Covering the peoples who live and have lived in an area or region, and how the unique features of the earth in that region have influenced and shaped human actions through history. For example, Rome being built where it was because of the rivers close by and the 7 hills which offer protection from attack.

However, after reading the two assigned readings for Essay 1, I find myself doubting my definition and feeling like I don't have a strong grasp of what geography is and thus I am not really certain what I am supposed to learn and come away with from this course.

I suppose the best answer to this is a comical "yes" .... let me explain this bizarre response ...

If the essays by Charles Wade and Alec Murphy left you wondering what exactly Geography is about, and what is one supposed to get from this field of inquiry, well, join the club.  You are not alone.  We geographers wrestle with this identity question everyday.

In fact, this is a question that took up a major chunk of the capstone course, GEOG495, that I taught this past spring term.  I think I drove the students in the class a tad crazy by harping on this theme; but then, come to think of it, I get paid to drive students crazy with questions.  (Though, I then remind myself about the fate that befell the teacher who annoyed the most--Socrates!)

I suppose in this course I can't go as deep into this theme as I would in the capstone course.  So, I will restrict myself to a few comments, but will happily provide more if there is any interest at all ...

Yes, geography has always been multi- and cross-disciplinary--sometimes it might seem like the discipline is like anthropology while at other times it might seem like geology or economics ... One reason is that geography has a long history; after all, to understand the planet ("geo") has been a project that, I suppose, ever since humans started thinking.  To some extent, it is then like a mother of many disciplines that came much later.  We have intellectual cousins in various fields of intellectual inquiry.

But, by the same token, one criticism has been that if Geography is about everything, then perhaps it is nothing.  It is one hell of a serious critique.  Because, for instance, a physicist has a clear idea of the discipline and where the disciplinary boundaries are.  But that is not the case with geographers.  And when in the modern world of intellectual activities, it is specialization that defines disciplines and the professionals, the spread out discipline makes it seem as if Geography has no specific focus at all.

You see how important and interesting the question you raised is?  Absolutely fascinating, and we can spend hours/days talking about this.  But, I shall pause here on this and wait for any follow-up the class might have.

So, then what would you get from this course, or how can you make sense of this course?  On the one hand, it is kind of ridiculous to group countries into "regions" and study them.  Because, there is almost always tremendous differences within the regions with respect to their physical and human geographic attributes.  Take Sub-Saharan Africa, for instance.  Only a completely mis-informed person would think there is no difference internally ... and this is a question that Moses Ochonu discusses, right?  Neither is there any kind of "scientific law" that we could apply to regions.  I.e., we could not possibly predict that if a country is located in a certain region, then a certain "x" will be the economic output, for instance.

This course is, therefore, to be approached not at an upper division level, but, as I noted quite early on, is really a freshman- or a sophomore-level course.  This is one way in which we can begin to appreciate the tremendous complexity in the world.  For instance, when we look at the Indian Subcontinent, in the first place, we begin to understand where it is located in the first place.  Then we realize the immense internal differences in every possible way--deserts to valleys to languages to religions to ...  The course then slowly wakes us up the reality that the ideas that we might have of different parts of the world could be absolutely screwed up.  Perhaps it will then force us to understand more about the world and the different issues.

An example of a very big picture thinking on this is the book, Guns, Germs, and Steel.  But, in order to get to this complex big picture, we first need to know the basics about the world--hence, this course.

I hope I have stayed on task in responding to the question and have not wandered off ... I will be delighted to "talk" more if any of you have pointed follow-up questions

And, yes, thanks for the question that prompted this response.